Tongues And Prophecy - Benefit For Whom?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rofl - we agree CW - but the language was human not a non language as you are trying to "prove" as a tongue no one understands and "edifies" no one including the speaker. In the case of then Apostles, they knew what they were saying - it was the crowd who heard in their native HUMAN languages.

We alway have to search the scriptures for truth. We can never assume what is truth. when the Bible says.....

1Co 14:14 For if I pray in an unknown tongue, my spirit prayeth, but my understanding is unfruitful.

The 120 that were speaking in tongues did not have a clue to what they were saying because it was given them by the Holy Spirit.
If it was a learned language they were speaking then there would be no big deal going on.

All speaking in tongues is never a learned language to the one speaking it.
 
If you don't understand what you are saying to God - you won't learn any mysteries. You said several posts back, CW, that you don't want to speak in tongues, you just do. Post 179 says you have to ask - why? Nevermind. So which is it? You have to ask or you just speak in an unknown to any one as the compulsion pulls you? There's a tape of a pastor on Youtube who asked and didn't get tongues and he asked sincerely many times. Maybe the real HS in him stopped it.
 
Just to be clear as to where I stand in regards to my faith in Jesus Christ, when a person comes to & believe in Jesus Christ, they are filled to such a point as Jesus promised; that they would hunger and thirst no more to be filled ( John 6:35 ) and thus they are complete in Christ, after having received Him. Colossians 2:5-10 Our always being filled with the Spirit is a testimony that we are a new creature in Christ Jesus as born again and thus sealed with that Holy Spirit of promise like new wineskin able to hold the new wine for ever so we can testify that Jesus Christ is our Savior because we are saved. Matthew 9:17

Saved believers that seek another filling to be able ministers should not preach to that ( 2 Corinthians 11:3-4 ) because there is no more filling with the Spirit ( 1 Corinthians 12:13 ) and no other hope of our calling to be filled. Ephesians 4:4-6

2 Corinthians 3:1Do we begin again to commend ourselves? or need we, as some others, epistles of commendation to you, or letters of commendation from you? 2 Ye are our epistle written in our hearts, known and read of all men: 3 Forasmuch as ye are manifestly declared to be the epistle of Christ ministered by us, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God; not in tables of stone, but in fleshy tables of the heart. 4 And such trust have we through Christ to God-ward: 5 Not that we are sufficient of ourselves to think any thing as of ourselves; but our sufficiency is of God; 6 Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit: for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.

No minister need an extra commendation or an extra filling of the Spirit to be an able minster of how he or she was saved.

So I agree with you that one that does not speak in tongues, that does not mean they are not Spirit-filled, BUT just as we do not need tongues to validate that we are Spirit-filled, saved believers do not need a second filling to validate them to be an able minister of Jesus Christ of Whom we believe.

Elders can anoint a saved believer will oil, but that is all they are anointing with because saved believers already have Him as promised by faith in Jesus Christ.


TJ, I'm with you on almost everything you say, especially about Isa 8:19, but the elders in Antioch laid hands on Barnabas and Saul for ministry Acts 13:2, 3, notice they were so doing in obeying the command of the Holy Spirit for the particular ministry He had chosen for them in the Body of Christ and later Paul would exhort young Timothy to not neglect the gift the Holy Spirit had given him through prophecy and by the laying on of hands of the elders 1 Tim 4:14, Paul also instructed Timothy to not lay hands on a novice 1 Tim 5:22.

So it seems the Holy Spirit does tell us there is something more than the indwelling we receive when born again, personally, I look at it this way, ...when I was born again, I received the Holy Spirit, ...when it was clear to the elders in my church the call of the Holy Spirit on my life, they laid hands on me and the Holy Spirit received me, ...what did I receive from this filling, baptism or whatever anyone wants to call it, faith, I was filled with faith, ...the Lord called me here and I was to come on a one way ticket (impossible for a non-French citizen), without any documents that would allow me to stay longer than three months as a tourist and without any financial aid from my church or friends, when the Lord gave me these conditions I was filled with wonder as to how it could happen and believe me I tried my best to help Him, all to no avail, there were some in my church that doubted His call on my life and sometimes I allowed their doubt to settle on me, this went on for almost a year from when He called me to the day before I left, ...the day the elders laid hands on me for this missionary trip, all doubt and wonder instantly vanished and I was sure, I knew deep in my soul the Father would accomplish what He had told me to do, all that was required of me was to step out in faith and trust Him with the rest, I was stopped at the SFO check-in counter, but He opened the door, I was detained at the FAA'A Airport French Immigration, but He opened the door, I hit the shores without a penny in my pocket, but He fed me and housed me (unlike His son I have always had a place to lay my head, even if it was only a bench in the employees lunch room), and I lived here for 3 1/2 years without any official papers, questioned twice by French Immigration during that time and then He told me to go to a particular church on the sister island of where I was living and that day He introduced me to His Eve for me, ...incidentally, she had been praying for 12 years for an American husband that played an instrument and loved working with children, ...that's me and with this marriage I became a Naturalized French citizen, they can't deport me now.

You see bro, I did receive something from the Holy Spirit that day hands were laid on me, ...because I have lived a daily life of faith in Father providing for me, I'm considered a freak, or a monster by most of the church, ...because of my faith, like James says,

Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works. Jas 2:18

Like I said, the day I was born again I got the Holy Spirit, the day hands were laid on me the Holy Spirit got me!

Blessings,

Gene
 
If you don't understand what you are saying to God - you won't learn any mysteries. You said several posts back, CW, that you don't want to speak in tongues, you just do. Post 179 says you have to ask - why? Nevermind. So which is it? You have to ask or you just speak in an unknown to any one as the compulsion pulls you? There's a tape of a pastor on Youtube who asked and didn't get tongues and he asked sincerely many times. Maybe the real HS in him stopped it.

I speak in tongues because the Bible teaches it. If it did not I would not have it. I want everything the Lord has for me. Most of every thing I have ever learned from the Lord was by asking God for interpretation of tongues. He always confirms everything by His Word and the Holy Spirit bears witness to whatever the Father teaches. There will always be a false tongues as the Devil deceives in any way he can. He is the one who said, "I will ascend above the clouds, I will be LIKE the most high..." He is trying to be a false copy of the real.
 
For he that speaketh in an unknown language (tongue) speaketh not unto men, but unto God: for no man understandeth him; howbeit in the spirit he speaketh mysteries. 1Co 14:2

What I don't understand is why is this so hard to understand, on the day of Pentecost, there were only 16, 17 different languages spoken, not 120, now put yourself in the place of one of those that were speaking in, let's say Arabian or Egyptian (have you ever heard either one of those languages and how strange they sound to an English speaking ear) the wonderful works of God, ...here is a first time, supernatural phenomenon coming out of your mouth, ...don't you think it would be a mystery to you?

Blessings,

Gene
 
I speak in tongues because the Bible teaches it. If it did not I would not have it. I want everything the Lord has for me. Most of every thing I have ever learned from the Lord was by asking God for interpretation of tongues. He always confirms everything by His Word and the Holy Spirit bears witness to whatever the Father teaches. There will always be a false tongues as the Devil deceives in any way he can. He is the one who said, "I will ascend above the clouds, I will be LIKE the most high..." He is trying to be a false copy of the real.

Okay CWW (and I don't mean to offend), let's be 100% Scriptural and follow the Word, in not one instance, where speaking in tongues is recorded in the Book of Acts, did the person ask for the gift, ...so, did you ask for the gift?

Blessings,

Gene
 
For he that speaketh in an unknown language (tongue) speaketh not unto men, but unto God: for no man understandeth him; howbeit in the spirit he speaketh mysteries. 1Co 14:2

What I don't understand is why is this so hard to understand, on the day of Pentecost, there were only 16, 17 different languages spoken, not 120, now put yourself in the place of one of those that were speaking in, let's say Arabian or Egyptian (have you ever heard either one of those languages and how strange they sound to an English speaking ear) the wonderful works of God, ...here is a first time, supernatural phenomenon coming out of your mouth, ...don't you think it would be a mystery to you?

Blessings,

Gene
There is no doubt speaking in a UNKNOWN tongue is a mystery to the one speaking it. It is even more amazing that someone is understanding what you are saying when you don't, unless he prays that he may interpret.
 
I get no joy from debating about tongues, healing, and prophecy. I think all the prophecy we need is right in the Bible. I think God continues to heal folks. I have been gifted plenty by God and if He wants for me to have more, He will give it, as I need it. God told me to learn and understand and babbling would be counter productive to me. If you understand what you are praying to God and you learn what truly conforms to His Word, I have no problem with your private practice. I don't believe scripture tells us to use tongues. Those who do, I advise they test to make sure. I have learned more from TalkJesus, who does not speak in tongues about scripture than I do from any who have promoted tongues. I have learned much from Abdicate, who does - so I keep my mind open.
 
Okay CWW (and I don't mean to offend), let's be 100% Scriptural and follow the Word, in not one instance, where speaking in tongues is recorded in the Book of Acts, did the person ask for the gift, ...so, did you ask for the gift?

Blessings,

Gene
Yes I did. Remember ministry gifts (tongues) are given as the Spirit wills not as man wills. But being filled with the Holy Spirit is given to those who ask for it.

Luk 11:13 If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children: how much more shall your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to them that ask him?

Also, remember the 120 were expecting, and wanting the Holy Spirit to come to them so they might be receive power as Jesus told them.

Luk 24:49 And, behold, I send the promise of my Father upon you: but tarry ye in the city of Jerusalem, until ye be endued with power from on high.
 
Last edited:
I get no joy from debating about tongues, healing, and prophecy. I think all the prophecy we need is right in the Bible. I think God continues to heal folks. I have been gifted plenty by God and if He wants for me to have more, He will give it, as I need it. God told me to learn and understand and babbling would be counter productive to me. If you understand what you are praying to God and you learn what truly conforms to His Word, I have no problem with your private practice. I don't believe scripture tells us to use tongues. Those who do, I advise they test to make sure. I have learned more from TalkJesus, who does not speak in tongues about scripture than I do from any who have promoted tongues. I have learned much from Abdicate, who does - so I keep my mind open.
Thats OK, as Jesus said, "be it done unto you according to your faith" There is no condemnation to those who don't speak in tongues. Salvation is not based on that. As for me I need, and want everything the Lord has provided for me. I am not a bashful person when it comes to the things of God.
 
Last edited:
NO ONE is saying that miracles have stopped. Or that God stopped healing. When man wants to claim he does what God is responsible for, something is wrong with your theology. If I lay my hands on you and you are healed - that's God - He doesn't need my hands. Self proclaimed healers have zero medically documented, verified healings. Don't you find that odd? And yet daily, God heals and it is medically certified that the doctors don't know how it was done. I am joyous for your wife - but it was God who healed her - not man.

So... In that context... You may be on to something here that's been sitting under my nose all along.....

Proposition #1.... Let's say a GIFT is something you RECEIVE from God and NOT something you Give....
Proposition #2.... People do have Callings.... and God prepares you for your Calling/Ministry....
Proposition #3... Even though some Callings have the Same Name as some Gifts - there is a difference...

So... In this context....
Teaching - the Gift would be the Miraculous understanding of some important point.....
where Teaching - the Calling is your ability to teach OTHERS God's truths....

So.. We could in fact have Healing - the Gift.. where God grants miraculous healing through the power of his Spirit....
BUT... Healing - the Calling.... is a whole lot more mundane... Aka - your local Doctor.... who heals people and uses plenty of wisdom to do it... but it's not quite so "miraculous"....

Same with Compassion or help or encouragement - where God reaches out His hand when YOU are in need..

In this context - we could Receive miraculous Gifts... such as Healing... but that Gift only implies that the Holy Spirit is still at work... Not that there is someone who OWNS the claim to dole such things out....

So... In this context - the CLAIM that My Wife has received God's Gift of healing means that She was miraculously healed by God.... But... There is no claim that SHE can somehow heal others because of that same Gift... The Gift was something God did for Her.... I can buy that....

Hmmm....... Lots to think about
 

NO ONE is saying that miracles have stopped. Or that God stopped healing. When man wants to claim he does what God is responsible for, something is wrong with your theology. If I lay my hands on you and you are healed - that's God - He doesn't need my hands. Self proclaimed healers have zero medically documented, verified healings. Don't you find that odd? And yet daily, God heals and it is medically certified that the doctors don't know how it was done. I am joyous for your wife - but it was God who healed her - not man.

You will not find a man or woman of God to whom God used mightily for His kingdom whether by a healing ministry or any other calling to say it was was by their own hand these things were done. Even Jesus never claimed to do anything on his own, but it was his Father in him doing the Works. The Apostle Paul said that he labored more than any man, but also said it was not him, but the grace of God in him who was doing it.
The only people to claim they were doing anything were those to whom Jesus said, "I never knew you"
 
So... In that context... You may be on to something here that's been sitting under my nose all along.....

Proposition #1.... Let's say a GIFT is something you RECEIVE from God and NOT something you Give....
Proposition #2.... People do have Callings.... and God prepares you for your Calling/Ministry....
Proposition #3... Even though some Callings have the Same Name as some Gifts - there is a difference...

So... In this context....
Teaching - the Gift would be the Miraculous understanding of some important point.....
where Teaching - the Calling is your ability to teach OTHERS God's truths....

So.. We could in fact have Healing - the Gift.. where God grants miraculous healing through the power of his Spirit....
BUT... Healing - the Calling.... is a whole lot more mundane... Aka - your local Doctor.... who heals people and uses plenty of wisdom to do it... but it's not quite so "miraculous"....

Same with Compassion or help or encouragement - where God reaches out His hand when YOU are in need..

In this context - we could Receive miraculous Gifts... such as Healing... but that Gift only implies that the Holy Spirit is still at work... Not that there is someone who OWNS the claim to dole such things out....

So... In this context - the CLAIM that My Wife has received God's Gift of healing means that She was miraculously healed by God.... But... There is no claim that SHE can somehow heal others because of that same Gift... The Gift was something God did for Her.... I can buy that....

Hmmm....... Lots to think about


You got it bro, and the next step in that parade is the Apostles were men that did have the gifts to introduce a new revelation from God concerning His Son Jesus Christ, ...but do we see any men, after the first century, that possess the gifts in the same way as the Apostles, not really, but what we do see today is men claiming Apostolic Authority along with weirdness and bizarreness concerning the gifts of the Holy Spirit, ...just like it was prophesied, by those first century Apostles, it would be in the end times.

Blessings,

Gene
 
JohnC - I have no idea if you are using sarcasm in your post. But I meant that God heals people in hospitals all the time and the doctors have no idea (scratch heads) as to how it happened. Medically documented healing - God did it. And I am not speaking to the non controversial gifts of the HS, ie: teaching, discernment-those are still seen. I'm talking about abuse of "tongues", self proclaimed healers who can't show any verifiable healing, and prophets with new revelations that are far less than the biblical 100%. Pastors who promise healing with their hands out and if you don't get healed - it's your own fault/lack of faith - give more $$$. I'm never getting past with tongues that God needs to pray to Himself.. .And I don't see in scripture that the Tongues used today are what scripture clearly states about them. I know the HS works in mine and every Christian's life. If spirit comes to me I ask, " do you confess Christ as your Savior". If not it goes away. If it is of God, it stays. I know God doesn't love me any more than you and that we don't "earn" His love. I'm joyous about that. I try to always do what I see as God's Will because I love Him. I'm thankful. And I don't want to be separated from Him. I know I can be deceived, so I have His Word to keep me straight.
 
Yes I did. Remember ministry gifts (tongues) are given as the Spirit wills not as man wills. But being filled with the Holy Spirit is given to those who ask for it.

Luk 11:13 If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children: how much more shall your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to them that ask him?

Also, remember the 120 were expecting, and wanting the Holy Spirit to come to them so they might be receive power as Jesus told them.

Luk 24:49 And, behold, I send the promise of my Father upon you: but tarry ye in the city of Jerusalem, until ye be endued with power from on high.

I have no problem with what you are saying here, but I reiterate, in Acts no one is recorded as asking for either the Holy Spirit or speaking in tongues, He just fell on the people, and a correct exegesis of tongues in Acts proves that the Apostles had accomplished what Jesus had told them to do, preach the Gospel in Jerusalem, Samaria and to the ends of the world and to authenticate Paul as the twelfth Apostle and not Matthias.

What I do have a problem with is people that claim they speak in tongues, but what they speak is the same gibberish over and over year after year and not a known language on the planet today, ...so with that in mind, God authenticated speaking in tongues thirty years after the fact when Luke recorded what languages were spoken by the Spirit filled believers, so I make this challenge again, and please don't use the excuse others have voiced, that it would be an affront to God because He is the one that authenticated the seemingly gibberish the disciples spoke on the day of Pentecost, ...record what you say in tongues and let is use a language translator, in the spirit of 1 Thes 5:21, to approve it.

Blessings,

Gene
 
There is no doubt speaking in a UNKNOWN tongue is a mystery to the one speaking it. It is even more amazing that someone is understanding what you are saying when you don't, unless he prays that he may interpret.

Am I understanding yo correctly?

Are you saying the person that is hearing the language (tongues), like on the day of Pentecost must then pray to understand what he is hearing in his native language???
 
I have no problem with what you are saying here, but I reiterate, in Acts no one is recorded as asking for either the Holy Spirit or speaking in tongues, He just fell on the people, and a correct exegesis of tongues in Acts proves that the Apostles had accomplished what Jesus had told them to do, preach the Gospel in Jerusalem, Samaria and to the ends of the world and to authenticate Paul as the twelfth Apostle and not Matthias.

What I do have a problem with is people that claim they speak in tongues, but what they speak is the same gibberish over and over year after year and not a known language on the planet today, ...so with that in mind, God authenticated speaking in tongues thirty years after the fact when Luke recorded what languages were spoken by the Spirit filled believers, so I make this challenge again, and please don't use the excuse others have voiced, that it would be an affront to God because He is the one that authenticated the seemingly gibberish the disciples spoke on the day of Pentecost, ...record what you say in tongues and let is use a language translator, in the spirit of 1 Thes 5:21, to approve it.

Blessings,

Gene
Brother, you are not making any sence to your request. He that speaks in an unknown tongue speaks not unto men, but unto God. For no man understands him. If no man understands him how can a universal translator know what is being said? It can not, because it is not a known language spoken here on earth.

1Co 14:2= For one who speaks in a tongue speaks not to men but to God; for no one understands him, but he utters mysteries in the Spirit.

You too are not understanding the difference between the "ministry" of tongues and praying in tongues. It is the Spirit of God that gives the interpretation to those listening to what is being said. It is not always in a known language. I would not call "gibberish" what the Holy Spirit gives to the one speaking, because God knows exactly what is being said. You are only assuming that all tongues is a known language spoken here on earth, which is not true.
 
Last edited:
Hardly comforting to those that don't for the next time when they don't know what to pray for, thus alluding to a necessity to seek tongues as a prayer language... and yet nowhere in scripture did Paul or anyone said to seek tongues for that purpose.
I disagree, but then only those that have it do it... so no sweat off my nose :)
 
Am I understanding yo correctly?

Are you saying the person that is hearing the language (tongues), like on the day of Pentecost must then pray to understand what he is hearing in his native language???

What ever the Spirit of God gives to the speaker to say is what will be said. They have no choice in what is being said. The person speaking in an unknown tongue does not care what is being said as he knows it will Glorify God no matter what language is being used because they trust in God. On the day of Pentecost these people did not chose what was being said or what language was being used.
 
What ever the Spirit of God gives to the speaker to say is what will be said. They have no choice in what is being said. The person speaking in an unknown tongue does not care what is being said as he knows it will Glorify God no matter what language is being used because they trust in God. On the day of Pentecost these people did not chose what was being said or what language was being used.

I think you are assuming things not written. The Apostles spoke in their own native language, and the hearer's heard in their own native language. With them all speaking at once, not in unison, it sounded strange, perhaps, to those who didn't have ears to hear. Maybe even joyous, it sounded.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top